Resending from Wed -don't think this went through either-? thx kw
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Karen Weaver <[log in to unmask]>
Date: Wed, 6 Apr 2011 18:30:37 -0400
Subject: Re: ELIS and number of programs
To: Open Lib/Info Sci Education Forum <[log in to unmask]>
What I am trying to point out especially here, is that this title as
others have indicated too, in their holdings of the title through
editions 1-2 were as a series.
It is also very likely many libraries have the ELIS -3 sitting on a
shelf somewhere if it is in print format waiting for someone to make a
decision also.
Again, if they do not have an online subscription to it.
There are series continuation records attached also to mongraphic
records to this series.
They can be separated in online catalogs certainly, but it leaves many
ghosts in the machine for libraries to clean up later. These are just
suggestions as to why one may not see holdings listed in WorldCat for
this 2010 edition under a monograph title.
Maybe someone can check all the schools and the library catalog
holdings instead of WorldCat. If they are currently claimed or on
order there usually would be a record for that as well. again,
records have existed previously as series/continuations for this
series, and I'm just making a suggestion as to why libraries may have
these holdings in other places or "on hold" esp for the print 3rd
edition if there have been changes of titles, and changes of series.
I have not checked one by one either, but maybe others can do some
further checking as they have interest also.
Best , Karen Weaver
On 4/6/11, Marcia J. Bates <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
> Folks,
>
> Karen Weaver has argued all along that there may be more copies
> around of ELIS 3 that I thought when I wrote my original post. I
> wish she were right, but as noted in the last post I just sent, I
> could find no evidence for that.
>
> As for the libraries listed below: I based my original statement
> that "about half of US and Canadian LIS programs have it" on the
> count for the OCLC listing of libraries owning ELIS3--in either print
> or online form, which Karen appears to have reproduced below. Within
> that listing, I counted the places with LIS programs--and it came out
> to about half the total US and Canadian programs.
>
> As far as I can see, nothing Karen has stated in her emails has shown
> that my original figures were in any way incorrect.
>
> Marcia
>
>
>
>
>>X-Sieve: CMU Sieve 2.3
>>DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed;
>> d=gmail.com; s=gamma;
>> h=domainkey-signature:mime-version:date:message-id:subject:from:to
>> :content-type;
>> bh=INmRiauF7qRa3sRboq8szIgxVETHQPY2rAYu8tSuNw0=;
>>
>> b=oq/MKhAXWjZRnZutEoNkssQ/6eNy0ZHS0274PSYE5yBr2GzGaIqAkvDNDlrtFUwZ8p
>>
>> nwTpy/zn70DdLyJupO44dZ8WLxapGkXpS0j4uscYTumvItGxKwOqzeb0h2yH+DGpXLIc
>> 8oVhDEP2iCWD+xJ3kVXoh5g2mh4wArgSy22r0=
>>Date: Mon, 4 Apr 2011 21:11:55 -0400
>>Subject: Cataloging ELIS3 -last one :-) worldcat
>>From: Karen Weaver <[log in to unmask]>
>>To: "Open Lib/Info Sci Education Forum" <[log in to unmask]>,
>> mjbates <[log in to unmask]>
>>X-Probable-Spam: no
>>
>>I think there are around 63 accredited programs (?)
>>here are records which I found recently when I first took a look ......
>>I would just suspect maybe some are using the old series record
>>possibly also....
>>again I have not checked individual libraries but it is quite possible
>>
>>You may have already seen these, sharing for general information &
>>anyone interested.
>>Best regards,
>> Karen Weaver
>>
>>
>>This record OCLC: 454373558 has 55 library holdings:
>>
>>Current database: WorldCat Total Libraries: 55
>>Title: Encyclopedia of library and information sciences Author: Bates,
>>Marcia J Accession Number: 454373558
>>Libraries with Item: "Encyclopedia of library a..."( Record for Item |
>>Get This Item )
>>Location Library Local Holdings Code
>>US,CA ALIBRIS ALBRS
>>US,CA CLAREMONT COL ACQRC HDC
>>US,CA UNIV OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY CUY
>>
>>US,DC LIBRARY OF CONGRESS DLC
>>US,DC US CENT INTELLIGENCE AG LCI
>>
>>US,FL FLORIDA ATLANTIC UNIV FGM
>>
>>US,GA VALDOSTA STATE UNIV GYG
>>
>>US,IA IOWA STATE UNIV IWA
>>
>>US,IL NORTHERN ILLINOIS UNIV JNA
>>US,IL UNIV OF ILLINOIS UIU
>>
>>US,IN INDIANA UNIV IUL
>>
>>US,LA LOUISIANA STATE UNIV LUU
>>
>>US,MD UNIV OF MARYLAND, COL PARK UMC
>>
>>US,MO MISSOURI STATE LIBR MOL
>>
>>US,NC EAST CAROLINA UNIV ERE
>>US,NC UNIV OF N CAROLINA, CHAPEL HILL NOC
>>
>>US,NE UNIV OF NEBRASKA AT LINCOLN LDL
>>
>>US,NH YBP LIBRARY SERVICES YDX
>>
>>US,NJ PRINCETON UNIV PUL
>>
>>US,NY CORNELL UNIV v.1-7 COO
>>US,NY MONROE COMMUN COL LIBR VQT
>>US,NY SUNY AT ALBANY NAM
>>
>>US,OH KENT STATE UNIV KSU
>>US,OH MIAMI UNIV MIA
>>US,OH OCLC LIBR OCC
>>
>>US,OR BLACKWELLS BOOK SERV BWX
>>
>>US,RI UNIV OF RHODE ISLAND RIU
>>
>>US,SD NORTHERN STATE UNIV NOS
>>
>>US,TX SAM HOUSTON STATE UNIV SHH
>>US,TX UNIV OF TEXAS, PAN AM TPN
>>
>>Australia ADELAIDE UNIV LE1
>>Australia HURSTVILLE CITY COUNCIL ATNHU
>>Australia NATIONAL LIBR OF AUSTRALIA AUT
>>Australia NORTHERN TERRITORY LIBR & INFO SERV T@N
>>Australia QUEENSLAND UNIV OF TECH GARDENS POINT QUUOT
>>Australia STATE LIBR OF NEW S WALES ZP1
>>Australia STATE LIBR OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA AULSA
>>Australia STATE LIBR OF VICTORIA APVIC
>>Australia UNIV OF TECH, SYDNEY LT1
>>
>>Belgium UNIV LIBR DE BRUXELLES EQY
>>
>>CA,ON COUTTS LIBR SERV CDX
>>CA,ON UNIV OF OTTAWA OTZ
>>CA,ON UNIV OF WESTERN ONTARIO UWO
>>
>>China SHANGHAI LIBR SLY
>>
>>Hong Kong CITY UNIV OF HONG KONG/RUN RUN SHAW LIBR CPV
>>
>>India CCS HARYANA AGRI UNIV INCCS
>>
>>Japan KINJO GAKUIN UNIV K4J
>>Japan NATIONAL DIET LIBR NHN
>>Japan WASEDA UNIV LIBR LWU
>>
>>Qatar WEILL CORNELL MED COL IN QATAR WCMCQ
>>
>>Singapore NANYANG POLYTECHNIC LIBR SINPL
>>
>>Slovenia COBISS.SI - IZUM SILIS
>>
>>South Africa DURBAN UNIV OF TECH T2N
>>
>>Taiwan NATIONAL CHENGCHI UNIV CEG
>>
>>United Kingdom BRITISH LIBR UKM
>>Record for Item: "Encyclopedia of library a..."( Libraries with Item )
>>
>>Get This Item
>>Availability: Check the catalogs in your library.
>>Libraries worldwide that own item: 55
>>
>>External Resources:
>>
>>Cite This Item
>>Find Related
>>More Like This: Search for versions with same title and author |
>>Advanced options ...
>>Title: Encyclopedia of library and information sciences.
>>Author(s): Bates, Marcia J.
>>Maack, Mary Niles.
>>Publication: Boca Raton, FL : CRC Press,
>>Edition: 3rd ed. / Marcia J. Bates, editor-in-chief ; Mary Niles
>>Maack, associate editor.
>>Year: 2010
>>Description: 7 v. (lxxxix, 5742 p., 64 p.) : ill., maps ; 29 cm.
>>Language: English
>>Contents: v. 1. Academic-Catalogs -- v. 2. CD-ROM-Domain -- v. 3.
>>Dublin-Information literacy -- v. 4. Information management-Lesbian --
>>v. 5. Libraries-Organizational -- v. 6. Pacific-Sociology -- v. 7.
>>Software-Zoological.
>>Standard No: ISBN: 9780849397127 (set : acid-free paper); 084939712X
>>(set : acid-free paper); 0849397081 (v. 1); 9780849397080 (v. 1);
>>0849397057 (v. 2); 9780849397059 (v. 2); 0849397049 (v. 3);
>>9780849397042 (v. 3); 9780849396748 (v. 4); 0849396743 (v. 4);
>>0849396735 (v. 5); 9780849396731 (v. 5); 0849396727 (v. 6);
>>9780849396724 (v. 6); 0849396697 (v. 7); 9780849396694 (v. 7);
>>National Library: 015362711 LCCN: 2009-40251
>>SUBJECT(S)
>>Descriptor: Library science -- Encyclopedias.
>>Information science -- Encyclopedias.
>>Note(s): Rev. ed. of: Encyclopedia of library and information science
>>/ edited by Miriam A. Drake. 2nd ed. c2003/ Includes bibliographical
>>references and index.
>>Class Descriptors: LC: Z1006; Dewey: 020/.3
>>Other Titles: Encyclopedia of library and information science.
>>Vendor Info: YBP Library Services Coutts Information Services
>>Blackwell Book Service (YANK COUT BBUS) $2,400.00
>>Document Type: Book
>>Entry: 20091001
>>Update: 20110107
>>Accession No: OCLC: 454373558
>>Database: WorldCat
>>-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>>This record OCLC: 540380335 has 26 library holdings - e-resource
>>
>>Current database: WorldCat Total Libraries: 26
>>Title: Encyclopedia of library and information sciences Author: Bates,
>>Marcia J Accession Number: 540380335
>>Libraries with Item: "Encyclopedia of library a..."( Record for Item |
>>Get This Item )
>>Location Library Local Holdings Code
>>US,PA FRANKLIN & MARSHALL COL LFM
>>
>>US,AZ UNIV OF ARIZONA AZU
>>
>>US,CA CALIFORNIA STATE UNIV, FULLERTON CFI
>>US,CA GETTY RES INST JPG
>>US,CA SAN JOSE STATE UNIV CSJ
>>US,CA UNIV OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY CUY
>>US,CA UNIV OF CALIFORNIA, LOS ANGELES CLU
>>
>>US,FL FLORIDA STATE UNIV FDA
>>US,FL UNIV OF S FLORIDA FHM
>>
>>US,KY UNIV OF KENTUCKY LIBR KUK
>>
>>US,MA SIMMONS COL SCL
>>
>>US,MN ST CATHERINE UNIV MNE
>>US,MN UNIV OF MINNESOTA, MINNEAPOLIS MNU
>>
>>US,NJ PRINCETON UNIV PUL
>>US,NJ RUTGERS UNIV NJR
>>
>>US,NY CORNELL UNIV Local Holdings Availa... COO
>>US,NY QUEENS COL XQM
>>US,NY SAINT JOHNS UNIV LIBR ZSJ
>>US,NY SUNY AT BUFFALO BUF
>>US,NY SYRACUSE UNIV SYB
>>
>>US,OK UNIV OF OKLAHOMA OKU
>>
>>US,TN UNIV OF TENNESSEE TKN
>>
>>US,TX UNIV OF N TEXAS INT
>>
>>US,WA UNIV OF WASHINGTON LIBR WAU
>>
>>US,WI UNIV OF WISCONSIN, MILWAUKEE GZN
>>
>>Taiwan FUJEN CATHOLIC UNIV FJUTW
>>Record for Item: "Encyclopedia of library a..."( Libraries with Item )
>>
>>Get This Item
>>Access:
>> http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title%7Edb=all%7Econtent=t917508581
>>Availability: Check the catalogs in your library.
>>Libraries worldwide that own item: 26
>>
>>External Resources:
>>
>>Cite This Item
>>Find Related
>>More Like This: Search for versions with same title and author |
>>Advanced options ...
>>Title: Encyclopedia of library and information sciences
>>Author(s): Bates, Marcia J.
>>Maack, Mary Niles.
>>Publication: Boca Raton, FL : CRC Press,
>>Edition: 3rd ed. / Marcia J. Bates, editor-in-chief ; Mary Niles
>>Maack, associate editor.
>>Year: 2010-
>>Language: English
>>Standard No: ISBN: 9780849397110; 0849397111
>>Access:
>> http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title%7Edb=all%7Econtent=t917508581
>>SUBJECT(S)
>>Descriptor: Library science -- Encyclopedias.
>>Information science -- Encyclopedias.
>>System Info: Mode of access: World Wide Web.
>>Note(s): Title from homepage (last viewed March 3, 2010)./ Rev. ed.
>>of: Encyclopedia of library and information science / edited by Miriam
>>A. Drake. 2nd ed. c2003./ Includes bibliographical references./ Online
>>version of the 3rd ed. of the Encyclopedia, with updates./ Also
>>available in print.
>>General Info: Access restricted to subscribing institutions. Other
>>format available: Print version:; Encyclopedia of library and
>>information sciences.; 3rd ed.; Boca Raton, FL : CRC Press, c2010
>>Class Descriptors: LC: Z1006; Dewey: 020/.3
>>Other Titles: Encyclopedia of library and information sciences
>>(Online); Encyclopedia of library and information science.
>>Material Type: Document (dct); Internet resource (url); eBook (ebk)
>>Document Type: Internet Resource; Computer File
>>Date of Entry: 20030709
>>Update: 20100730
>>Accession No: OCLC: 540380335
>>Database: WorldCat
>>-------------------------
>>
>>Other WorldCat records -- (maybe more...?)
>>Wellington NZ & U Montreal are listed on other records
>> OCLC: 640616654
>>OCLC: 631002681
>>OCLC: 671958492 Univ College Dublin
>
>
> --
> Marcia J. Bates, Ph.D.
> Professor Emerita
> Fellow, American Association for the Advancement of Science
> Editor, Encyclopedia of Library and Information Sciences, 3rd Ed.
> Department of Information Studies
> Graduate School of Education and Information Studies
> University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA)
> Los Angeles, CA 90095-1520 USA
> Tel: 310-206-9353
> Fax: 310-206-4460
> Web: http://www.gseis.ucla.edu/faculty/bates/
>
>
|
